The Rural Think Tank

…It's Different Out Here.

When Your Pastor Leaves: A Church’s Guide to the Interim Period

by brentlacydotcom

When a pastor leaves, a church enters one of the most vulnerable seasons of its life. This guide walks through the interim period — what to expect, how to stabilize, and how to prepare for what comes next. Plus: a free Interim Pastor Handbook from MinistryPlace.

When Your Pastor Leaves: A Church’s Guide to the Interim Period

It is the phone call every church dreads. Your pastor has resigned. Maybe it was expected — retirement, a move, a new calling. Maybe it was sudden — a moral failure, a health crisis, a family emergency. Either way, the result is the same: your church has entered one of the most vulnerable seasons of its life.

The interim period between pastors is not just a gap to be filled. It is a critical window that shapes the church’s future for years to come. Handle it well, and the church emerges stronger. Handle it poorly, and the next pastor inherits a mess they did not create.

What to Expect in the First 30 Days

The first month after a pastor leaves is characterized by grief, uncertainty, and a surprising amount of logistical chaos. Here is what typically happens:

Grief. Even when a departure is amicable, the congregation grieves. The pastor was not just an employee — they were a spiritual leader, a counselor, a presence at weddings and funerals. Give people permission to grieve. Do not rush past it.

Uncertainty. Who will preach next Sunday? Who will visit the hospital? Who will lead the board meeting? These practical questions need answers fast. The church board or deacons should meet within the first week to assign interim responsibilities.

Storytelling. People will tell stories about the departing pastor — some positive, some not. Let them. This is part of the grieving process. Resist the urge to either canonize or demonize. The truth is usually somewhere in between.

Interim Pastor vs. Transitional Pastor: What is the Difference?

These terms are often used interchangeably, but they describe two distinct roles with different purposes, training, and scope. Understanding the difference will help you make a better decision for your church.

What is an Interim Pastor?

An interim pastor is a short-term placeholder. Their primary job is to keep the church running week to week. They preach on Sundays, visit the sick, attend board meetings, and handle emergencies. They are not there to make major changes or set a new direction. They are there to maintain stability while the church prepares for a permanent pastor.

Think of an interim pastor like a temporary manager who keeps a business running between permanent CEOs. They follow existing policies. They do not restructure the company.

Interim pastors are often retired ministers, seminary students, or experienced preachers from neighboring churches. Some are paid; some serve voluntarily. The key trait is that they are available for a defined period and understand their role is to maintain, not to transform.

What is a Transitional Pastor?

A transitional pastor is something different entirely. This is a trained professional who specializes in guiding churches through the entire transition process — not just filling the pulpit, but actively leading the church through the hard work of change.

A transitional pastor does everything an interim pastor does, plus:

  • Guides the church through grief and identity work — helping the congregation process the loss of the previous pastor and rediscover who they are as a church
  • Addresses unresolved conflict — surfacing and resolving issues that were suppressed under the previous leadership
  • Conducts a church health assessment — evaluating finances, leadership structure, community engagement, and spiritual vitality
  • Prepares the church for the search process — helping the congregation define what they need in the next pastor and what they need to change about themselves first
  • Facilitates strategic planning — working with the board and leadership to set a vision for the future before the new pastor arrives

Transitional pastors typically have specific training in organizational change, conflict resolution, and church systems. Many are certified through denominational programs or organizations like the Interim Pastor Network. They are usually paid professionals, and their tenure is typically 12-18 months.

Which One Does Your Church Need?

Here is a practical way to think about it:

  • If your church is healthy, the departure was amicable, and you just need someone to preach while you search — an interim pastor is probably sufficient.
  • If there was conflict around the departure, if the church has been declining, or if you know deep changes are needed — a transitional pastor is worth the investment.
  • If you cannot afford either — a rotating team of guest preachers from neighboring churches can cover the pulpit, but you will need a strong board or lay leader to handle the non-preaching aspects of the transition.

For small and rural churches, the most common approach is a combination: a retired pastor or seminary student handles preaching and basic pastoral care, while a denominational consultant or trained lay leader guides the transition process. The key is making sure someone is responsible for each piece.

Securing Interim Pastoral Coverage

Every Sunday needs a sermon. Every hospital visit needs a pastor. Every crisis needs someone who can respond. Interim pastoral coverage is not optional — it is essential.

Options for interim coverage include:

  • A retired pastor from your area who can preach and provide basic pastoral care
  • A seminary student looking for preaching experience
  • A rotating team of guest preachers from neighboring churches
  • An interim pastor — a professional who specializes in guiding churches through transitions (your denomination may provide one)

The key is that someone is responsible for preaching and pastoral care every single week. Do not leave Sundays uncovered.

Addressing Unfinished Business

Here is the hard truth: if there were unresolved conflicts under the previous pastor, they will not disappear on their own. In fact, they often get worse during a transition, when there is no authoritative leader to mediate.

The interim period is the time to address these issues. This may mean:

  • Having difficult conversations about church direction
  • Resolving conflicts between members or factions
  • Dealing with financial irregularities or mismanagement
  • Confronting patterns of behavior that were tolerated under the previous pastor

A new pastor should not inherit a church full of unresolved issues. The interim period is your chance to clean house — not to avoid conflict, but to prepare the church for healthy new leadership.

Assessing Your Church’s Health

The interim period is also an opportunity for honest self-assessment. Without the pressure of a sitting pastor defending their tenure, the church can ask hard questions:

  • Are we reaching anyone who is not already a member?
  • Is our budget sustainable?
  • Do we have a leadership pipeline, or does everything depend on one person?
  • Are we serving our community, or just maintaining our building?
  • What would happen if we could not afford a full-time pastor?

These questions are not comfortable. But they are necessary. The answers will shape your search for the next pastor and determine whether the church is positioned for health or decline.

Preparing for the Search

Most small churches should plan on 12-18 months to find a new pastor. That may sound long, but rushing the process almost always leads to a poor fit. Here is a realistic timeline:

  • Months 1-3: Stabilize. Secure interim coverage. Address unfinished business.
  • Months 3-6: Assess. Conduct a church health assessment. Define what you need in a new pastor.
  • Months 6-12: Search. Form a search committee. Post the position. Review candidates.
  • Months 12-18: Call. Interview top candidates. Extend a call. Transition.

Download the free Pastor Search Committee Toolkit

Free Resource: Interim Pastor Handbook

MinistryPlace.net offers a free Interim Pastor Handbook designed specifically for small and rural churches navigating pastoral transitions. It covers:

  • What to do in the first 30 days after a pastor leaves
  • How to secure interim preaching and pastoral coverage
  • How to address unresolved conflict before the new pastor arrives
  • How to conduct a church health assessment during the interim
  • How to prepare a realistic job description for the next pastor
  • Sample timelines, checklists, and communication templates

Download the free Interim Pastor Handbook

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should the interim period last?

Plan on 12-18 months from the day the pastor leaves to the day the new pastor starts. Some transitions take longer. Rushing the process usually leads to a poor fit.

Should we hire an interim pastor or use guest preachers?

It depends on your budget and needs. A professional interim pastor can guide the church through the transition process, but they cost money. Guest preachers from neighboring churches can fill the pulpit for free, but they will not provide the same level of transitional leadership.

What if we cannot afford a full-time pastor?

Consider bi-vocational ministry. With 47% of evangelical pastors working a second job, bi-vocational ministry is not a compromise — it is a legitimate and biblical model. Download the free Bi-Vocational Pastor Handbook

How do we handle conflict during the transition?

Address it directly and early. If necessary, bring in a mediator — your denomination may provide this service. A new pastor should not inherit unresolved conflict.

More Resources

About the author: Brent Lacy has served in small-town and rural ministry for over 25 years, from youth pastor to bi-vocational senior pastor. He founded MinistryPlace.net to provide free, practical resources for small and rural church leaders. He also hosts the Rural Think Tank podcast. His books include Rural Youth Ministry and This is NOT DiY: Renovating the Local Congregation. Connect with Brent on Facebook and LinkedIn.

Sources:

Leave a Reply